Yesterday I went to the movies with Andrew, Jin, and Junior, a buddy of ours from intramurals basketball. I had planned for us to watch Push then sneak into Watchmen. I ended up paying for both movies because I felt convicted not to sneak in after I had made the plans with everyone, and I didn't want to change or cancel things. Anyway Watchmen was a pretty good movie, and really thought provoking. I just didn't like all of the unnecessary sex scences, giant blue penis scenes, and adultery that was going on. I felt like there were a lot of religious and political metaphors, and that the movie was a very well-written satire on humanity. I'm going to explain the story and then the anti-God, atheist, and deist themes I interpreted from the movie, so if you haven't seen the movie yet and then don't read ahead until you have because I will spoil the movie for you.
The setting of the movie takes place in an alternate history around President Nixon's time. The world is currently on the brink of World War III and facing eminent annihilation by nuclear war. There are costumed superheroes called Watchmen who are trying to protect the world. The story is narrated by Rorschach, who was one of the original team of Watchmen. Other characters in the story include The Comedian, Adrian, and Dr. Manhattan. The Comedian was another one of the original Watchmen, along with Rorsach. Adrian is allegedly the smartest man in the world, built a multi-billion dollar empire, and was also on the team of Watchmen before the team disbanded and everyone retired. Adrian believes that war is a threat because of limited resources; by finding a way to provide free energy to everyone, he believes that he could make war obsolete. Dr. Manhattan was a physicist who was involved in an accident, and through that accident gained godlike powers, including the ability to rearrange matter. Dr. Manhattan used his incredible power to win World War II for America, and is also the reason why the other countries arn't attacking America. Now for the fun part... the metaphors. I feel like there is so much more depth to things if I watch the movie again (which I'm unwilling to do).
I sensed an undertone of religious debate throughout the whole movie. During one part, The Comedian shoots a pregnate woman (probably pregnate with his child) in the presence of Dr. Manhattan. The Comedian then says something along the lines of, "....yes, yes I did shoot her. And you stood right by and watched it happen. You could have stoped me if you wanted to- turned the bullets to lead, the gun to snowflakes or something. But you didn't. You just stood there and watched. Don't pretend like you care... God help us all."
In this movie, Dr. Manhattan is used to metaphorically represent God. I know he claims not to be in the movie, but the writer still uses him as such. He can be in multiple places at once. He knows the past and the future at once, hinting that he is outside of time. He has divine powers and can rearrange molecules. The question I see posed by this scene is the popular athiest arguement, "If God cares, if God is so powerful and so loving, why is there suffering in the world? Why does he allow bad things to happen?"
There was a scene where Rorschach was in prison. He looks around him and sees the depravity of humanity and remarks, "...but God isn't responsible for how messed up our world is. We are."
This simple statement reflects the doctrine of total depravity; we really, really are that messed up, and it's not God's fault- it's ours. The mess and suffering we see in the world today is a result of sinful human nature.
During the movie, there was a scene when they talked about all the intricate pieces of a watch being assembled to form a functioning watch. One of the characters comment, "...maybe life has no meaning. It's just a series of coincidences that lead to conditions that allow for life to exist, like the pieces of a watch coming together."
This line reflects a popular apologetics (defense of the Christian faith) involving the order of the universe. The conditions for life are so specific that the chances of all these things comming together randomly to allow for life on earth is the same as shaking a jar with all the pieces of a watch until it randomly assembles into a perfectly functioning watch- in other words, impossible.
In another scene when Dr. Manhattan was interviewed, he said "A living body and a deceased body have the same number of molecules; structurally, there is no difference."
If the universe and life did happen completely by chance, then ultimately there is no meaning to life and no sanctity of life. This is point that some Christian apologeticists bring up, and the conclusion that some athiests have come to accept.
Throughout the whole movie, Dr. Manhattan is portrayed as becomming increasingly estranged by this world. It got to the point where he left Earth for Mars because he didn't know whether Earth was worth saving anymore. At the end of the movie he comes back for a bit, but then decides to go away again.
These are strongly deist themes. Deism is the belief that there is a God who created the universe, but he either abandoned his creation or doesn't care much about it. My view of deism is that it is basically an atempt to be athiest and still get around some of the loop holes of athiesm (such as the conditions of life apologetics mentioned earlier).
Rorschach uncovers the true plot at the end of the story. Adrian has been secreatly duplicating Dr. Manhattan's power. With it, he obliterated key cities in the world, wiping out billions of lives. Dr. Manhattan is framed for this incredibly evil act, and the world decides to call off the cold war and unite against the threat of Dr. Manhattan. By doing so, war ended and the world was unified.
I felt like this was the grand conclusion of the religious debate in the movie. This is a metaphor that ultimatly, religion is a scam. The existance of God is improbable and inconsequential; what does matter is that society is governed by religion, because only then can it function harmoneously. The final conclusion of the movie is this- God doesn't exist, and if he does, it doesn't matter. What does matter is for people to believe in the illusion of his existance, because only then will the world be a better place.
Adrian is the emblem of human achievement. He is the smartest man in the world, has strong leadership abilities, and built a multi-billion dollar company on his own after being oprhaned at the age of seventeen. The huge irony is that Adrian, who is ultimatly the villian in the movie, wins. His plan is executed perfectly, Dr. Manhattan is framed, and the world is unified and saved. This is a critique that humans don't need God and can ultimatly manage without him.
Whew. That took a lot longer to write than I wanted. My thoughts and points are a bit fragmented, because I've only seen the movie once and didn't put too much thought into it.
Recent Comments